Congress Co-Rapporteurs: Dismissal of elected mayors undermines the very nature of democracy

Co-Rapporteurs of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe on local democracy in Turkey call on the Turkish authorities to stop replacing democratically elected opposition party mayors with trustees.

David Eray (Switzerland, EPP/CCE) and Bryony Rudkin (United Kingdom, SOC/G/PD), Co-Rapporteurs of the Congress of Local and Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe on local democracy in Turkey, have made the following statement regarding the dismissal of the Co-Mayor of Van, Abdullah Zeydan:

“The recent dismissal of Abdullah Zeydan, Mayor of the Metropolitan Municipality of Van - member of the Turkish delegation to the Congress- and his replacement by an appointed official is a matter of grave concern. It cannot be ignored.

“Mr Zeydan’s mandate had been challenged by a provincial electoral board decision on 2 April 2024, but was subsequently reinstated by Turkey's Supreme Election Council.  This newest move against him is the last link in a chain of deliberate and calculated delegitimisation.

“Sadly, it is also part of a wider and undemocratic pattern. 

“Since Turkey’s 2024 local elections - observed by the Congress - ten mayors have been removed, resulting in the votes of close to four million voters being discarded. Many opposition mayors also face judicial proceedings, defamation lawsuits and long prison sentences.

“The specific practice of replacing democratically elected opposition party mayors with trustees is undermining the very nature of democracy, as both the Congress and the Venice Commission have made clear on many occasions. 

“At its last session, the Congress reaffirmed in Recommendation 519(2024) the need to abolish this practice and called on the authorities to ensure that ineligibility of candidates is assessed prior to the elections and based on a final criminal conviction. Candidates deemed eligible must be allowed to freely exercise their mandates, in line with the European Charter of Local Self-Government, which is binding on all Council of Europe member States. In the event of a mayor’s dismissal, municipal councils should be able to choose a replacement mayor.

“We will bring these latest developments to the attention of the Congress Monitoring Committee on 25 February 2025 in Strasbourg, where we will have an exchange of views with members of the Turkish delegation attending the meeting. In the meantime, we reiterate our call to the Turkish authorities to stop this practice and resume the political dialogue with the Congress rapporteurs to ensure the effective implementation of past recommendations.”